LLNL researchers develop real-time defect detection in metal Additive Manufacturing

March 7, 2023

A team from LLNL developed a method for detecting and predicting strut defects in additively manufactured metal lattice structures during the build stage. Pictured is a sample lattice structure, celebrating the lab's seventieth anniversary, built by Gabe Guss (Courtesy Jean-Baptiste Forien/LLNL)
A team from LLNL developed a method for detecting and predicting strut defects in additively manufactured metal lattice structures during the build stage. Pictured is a sample lattice structure, celebrating the lab’s seventieth anniversary, built by Gabe Guss (Courtesy Jean-Baptiste Forien/LLNL)

A team of engineers and scientists from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL), California, USA, has developed a method for detecting and predicting strut defects in additively manufactured metal lattice structures during the build stage. The process, involving a combination of monitoring, imaging techniques and multi-physics simulations, enables users to determine if the part will satisfy quality requirements at the earliest possible stage.

The high-strength and low-density properties of metallic lattices have found applications in many fields. However, during the Laser Beam Powder Bed Fusuon (PBF-LB) process, missing or defective struts can occur that affect the mechanical behaviour of the lattice structure. To ensure quality, scientists typically perform a post-build inspection, which takes time and is not always possible, especially with complex builds.

TRUSTED CONTENT. TARGETED AUDIENCE
Advertise with Metal AM and access a global base of 50,000+ AM professionals
Contact us

As described in a paper recently published in Additive Manufacturing Letters, LLNL researchers monitored the Additive Manufacturing of a metallic micro-lattice structure using a photodiode, a pyrometer — both of which measure light emitted from the melt pool — and thermal imaging. The team produced normal struts and intentionally defective ‘half-struts’ through the PBF-LB process, measuring the thermal emissions from the melt pool. The researchers then developed a method to use those thermal emissions to predict defects with high accuracy.

Schematic of the experimental setup and sample design lattice additively manufactured using an octet truss unit cell. The lattice structure contains intentional full and top-half struts randomly positioned. Horizontal struts as well as vertical walls were omitted in the rendering for clarity (Courtesy Forien, Jean-Baptiste, et al, “Detecting missing struts in metallic micro-lattices using high speed melt pool thermal monitoring”, Additive Manufacturing Letters)
Schematic of the experimental setup and sample design lattice additively manufactured using an octet truss unit cell. The lattice structure contains intentional full and top-half struts randomly positioned. Horizontal struts as well as vertical walls were omitted in the rendering for clarity (Courtesy Forien, Jean-Baptiste, et al, “Detecting missing struts in metallic micro-lattices using high speed melt pool thermal monitoring”, Additive Manufacturing Letters)

“For the first time, this quality-control process was studied in metallic lattices and we developed a methodology to detect defective struts with a missing bottom part,” stated Jean-Baptiste Forien, lead author and LLNL staff scientist. “At the moment, we are capable of detecting defects that span multiple layers, but in the future, new methods will be developed to identify defects within a printed layer. This will allow a dynamic reaction and potentially the suppression of the defect before resuming printing of the rest of the build.”

The team developed their defect detection/prediction method based on observations from the test builds, high-speed imaging and multi-physics simulations of the PBF-LB melt pool. By monitoring thermal emission, researchers could predict whether a strut was present or missing with accuracy of more than 94%, validating the mechanisms behind the observed thermal emissions through high-speed thermal and optical imaging, and simulations using the ALE3D (Arbitrary Lagrangian–Eulerian three-dimensional analysis) multiphysics simulation tool developed by LLNL.

Co-authors of “Detecting missing struts in metallic micro-lattices using high speed melt pool thermal monitoring” included LLNL scientists and engineers Gabe Guss, Saad Khairallah, William Smith, Philip DePond, Manyalibo “Ibo” Matthews and principal investigator Nick Calta.

www.llnl.gov

In the latest issue of Metal AM magazine

Download PDF
 

Extensive AM industry news coverage, as well as the following exclusive deep-dive articles:

  • LEAP 71: Why engineering must move beyond CAD to realise the promise of AI and Additive Manufacturing
  • Additive Manufacturing and European defence: a critical opportunity as the US and China accelerate ahead
  • A market analyst’s view: Europe’s opportunity as defence AM surges in the US and China
  • From Fixed Processes to flight parts: How REM’s advanced surface finishing supports NASA JPL’s AM innovations
  • The future of large metal parts: WAAMathon #2 showcases developments in Wire Arc Directed Energy Deposition
  • Wire Electron Beam Directed Energy Deposition (DED): Advancing productivity and sustainability in metal AM
  • Building trust in AM: How Qualified AM GmbH is enabling regulated production at scale

TRUSTED CONTENT. TARGETED AUDIENCE

Advertise with Metal AM and access a global base of 50,000+ AM professionals.

Contact Jon Craxford: [email protected]

  • AM machines
  • Process monitoring & calibration
  • Heat treatment & sintering
  • HIP systems & services
  • Pre- & post-processing technology
  • Powders, powder production and analysis
  • Part manufacturers
  • Consulting, training & market data

Don’t miss a thing – register for our newsletter

Don't miss any new issue of Metal AM magazine, and get the latest industry news. Sign up to our twice weekly newsletter.

Register now

Join 40,000+ other AM professionals – follow us online

About Metal Additive Manufacturing magazine

Metal AM magazine, published quarterly in digital and print formats, is read by a rapidly expanding international audience.

Our audience includes component manufacturers, end-users, materials and equipment suppliers, analysts, researchers and more.

In addition to providing extensive industry news coverage, Metal AM magazine is known for exclusive, in-depth articles and technical reports.

Our focus is the entire metal AM process from design to application.

Each issue is available as an easy-to-navigate digital edition and a high-quality print publication.

Discover our magazine archive…

The free to access Metal Additive Manufacturing magazine archive offers unparalleled insight into the world of metal Additive Manufacturing from a commercial and technological perspective through:

  • Reports on visits to leading metal AM part manufacturers and industry suppliers
  • Articles on technology and application trends
  • Information on materials developments
  • Reviews of key technical presentations from the international conference circuit
  • International industry news

All past issues are available to download as free PDFs or view in your browser.

Browse the archive

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap